Do Consumers Care About Sustainability?

 

Do Consumers Care About Sustainability... or Do Companies Need Them to?



Companies have built strategies around what shoppers say in surveys. Their choices at the checkout tell a more complicated story.

For more than 25 years, sustainability has followed me through nearly every corner of my career in agricultural communications.

I have written about researchers trying to produce more with fewer resources, farmers balancing environmental goals with economic reality and companies positioning new products as better for agriculture and emerging markets like sustainable aviation fuel. I have watched sustainability move from a specialized topic to a corporate priority, a marketing strategy and, eventually, a word attached to almost everything.

Some of that change has been meaningful. Agriculture has made real advances in efficiency, conservation and environmental stewardship. But the longer I cover sustainability, the more I question one of the assumptions underneath all this work: Do consumers care as much as companies think they do?

Companies routinely point to surveys showing people value sustainability and say they will pay more for sustainable products. Those findings appear in presentations, product launches and corporate strategies as proof of growing demand.

But saying sustainability matters is easy. Choosing it at the checkout, when it costs more, performs differently or requires deciphering another vague label, is something else.

Consumers may care about climate, waste and responsible production. They may also care more, in the moment, about price, quality, taste and convenience. That does not make them dishonest or indifferent. It may mean companies have mistaken general approval for purchasing intent.

After years of writing about sustainability, I no longer think the most useful question is whether consumers care. The better question is what they are actually willing to give up for it.

What We Say and What We Buy

At first glance, the surveys support everything companies want to believe.

PwC’s 2024 Voice of the Consumer Survey found that 80% of consumers said they would pay more for sustainably produced or sourced goods. The average premium they claimed they would accept was 9.7%.

Those numbers could help justify almost any sustainability strategy. They also come with an important warning. PwC acknowledged that inflation, economic uncertainty and cost-of-living pressures could keep those intentions from turning into actual purchases.

Consumers may mean what they say in a survey and still make a different decision when they see the price on the shelf.

Research focused on food makes the conflict even clearer. The International Food Information Council’s 2026 Food & Health Survey found that taste influenced 88% of Americans’ food and beverage purchases. Price followed at 78%, convenience at 61% and healthfulness at 56%.

Environmental sustainability came in at 30%.

That does not prove consumers do not care. It shows sustainability must compete with concerns that feel more immediate.

A shopper may want food produced with less environmental impact, but she also wants something her family will eat. She may prefer responsible packaging, but she has a grocery budget. She may believe climate change matters and still reach for the familiar product that costs less.

Sustainability rarely gets to stand on its own. The product still has to taste good. It has to work. It has to be available, understandable and affordable. Sustainability can strengthen the choice, but it cannot always rescue a product that falls short somewhere else.

When Sustainability Becomes the Sales Pitch

Companies may also be overestimating sustainability because they have spent years marketing it as a consumer benefit.

The language is familiar: responsibly sourced, climate-smart, regenerative, lower impact, recyclable and environmentally friendly. Some of those claims represent real work. Others ask shoppers to understand complicated production systems, trust a company’s interpretation and decide that an environmental benefit justifies a higher price.

That is a lot to ask from someone standing in a grocery aisle.

A 2025 Blue Yonder survey of more than 5,000 consumers found that 78% considered sustainability at least somewhat important when choosing a product or retailer. Nearly two-thirds said they would spend more on sustainable products.

Yet only 29% had shifted their loyalty toward companies they considered more sustainable. Just 20% believed brands accurately represented their sustainability efforts.

That gap should make marketers pause.

Consumers have heard sustainability claims for years. What they often have not received is a clear explanation of what changed, why it matters and who verified it. Companies have added more language, but not always more clarity.

The strongest sustainability messages may not lead with sustainability at all. They connect environmental progress to something people already value: less waste, lower costs, better quality, longer product life or stronger performance.

A package that keeps food fresh longer reduces waste. A product that uses fewer resources but works just as well removes the trade-off. A more efficient production system may lower costs over time. Those are tangible benefits. “Better for the planet” is harder to evaluate, especially when dozens of brands make some version of the same claim.

The Blue Yonder research also found that 41% of U.S. consumers believed brands should bear primary responsibility for sustainability. That raises a question companies may not be asking: What if consumers care about sustainability but do not think they should have to pay extra for it?

A business may see sustainability as a premium feature. A shopper may see it as part of the company’s basic responsibility to reduce waste, use resources wisely and limit environmental harm.

Those are very different value propositions.

What the Shopping Cart Tells Us

It would be easy to look at these contradictions and declare sustainability nothing more than a buzzword. The evidence does not support that conclusion either.

The NYU Stern Center for Sustainable Business uses Circana purchasing data to track products marketed with sustainable attributes across 36 consumer packaged-goods categories. Its 2025 analysis found that those products held 25.4% of the branded market and accounted for nearly 45% of consumer packaged-goods growth from 2013 through 2025.

That is actual purchasing data, not a statement of intent. Sustainability has commercial value.

But those findings do not prove that every claim motivates consumers, every shopper will accept a premium or sustainability can outrank the fundamentals of a good product. They suggest consumers respond when sustainability is built into something that already meets their needs.

Perhaps the gap between what consumers say and what they buy is not evidence of hypocrisy. Perhaps companies have been asking an abstract question and expecting a commercial answer.

Consumers can care deeply about sustainability and still refuse to pay more for a product they do not trust, cannot afford or do not like. They can support environmental progress without treating every trip through the checkout line as a referendum on the planet.

Companies need to stop asking only whether consumers care. They need to ask whether the sustainable choice is credible, accessible and worth choosing on every other measure that matters.

Caring is not the same as buying. After decades of sustainability messaging, companies should understand the difference.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

When You're Ready to Go But Not Quite Ready to Leave

Are We Measuring Impact or Just Attention?

Blue Wave, Red Farm Belt: New Congress, Unfinished Farm Bill